The president's remarks during a news conference in the
Rose Garden came on the heels of growing doubts among many
fellow Republicans about the administration's commitment
to erecting a Congress-approved physical barrier to block
the routes most favored by smugglers sneaking illegal
immigrants across the nearly 2,000-mile border.
Those concerns have
been stoked by reports that Homeland Security Secretary
Michael Chertoff favors a high-tech solution utilizing
motion detectors and other kinds of sensors, cameras,
ground-based radars and a variety of computer-driven
devices to help police the border.
Critics of the high-tech approach say the experience
with the double-layered fencing erected a decade ago along
San Diego County's border with Tijuana shows that only a
physical impediment is likely to be effective. They worry
that any other kind of solution could be circumvented,
possibly by smugglers who overwhelm the system's
vulnerable points by unleashing vast numbers of illegal
border-crossers at one time.
Asked about Chertoff's reported preference for a
virtual barrier versus a physical fence, Bush said, “We're
going to do both,” including, he added, utilizing a
“combination of fencing and technologies – UAVs, sensors.”
Later, Rep. Duncan Hunter, R-Alpine, who co-sponsored
legislation requiring the construction of double-layered
fencing, said in a telephone interview: “The president
will build that fence. I am confident of that. And
certainly we will use surveillance, but it will not be a
substitute for fencing where you can build fencing.”
Some conservatives fear that the administration may not
fully fund the 700-mile fence, estimated to cost $12
billion. Bush did not address that concern. So far, only a
$1.2 billion down payment has been appropriated to build
the fence.
Bush also used the news conference to reiterate his
support for a guest-worker program as part of what he
described as a “comprehensive” solution to the highly
politicized problem of an illegal-immigrant population in
the United States of about 12 million.
Many Republican candidates in Senate and House races
far removed from the U.S.-Mexican border have denounced
such plans for providing opportunities for many illegal
immigrants to become legal residents over time. At least
some Democratic candidates who have embraced legislation
patterned after the White House's plan have been attacked
by their GOP adversaries as favoring “amnesty” for illegal
immigrants.
Bush did not directly address the policy and political
disconnect between his immigration policy and the
preference of many Republicans for an enforcement-only
approach.
He did argue: “When you've got a situation where people
are sneaking in to do jobs Americans aren't doing, it's
. . . going to keep a strain on the border. And so,
therefore, a temporary-worker plan to me makes sense, and
it's a much more humane . . . approach.”